January 13, 2015
Dear Senator Cruz,
I received your recent letter with
reports of your work in the 114th Congress, so here is my letter in
response. This is not so much a point-by-point political argument about the
ways you and I would approach our state’s problems and solutions (although you
and I do seem to have very different opinions on many of these matters). Rather, since I am a Christian
minister, this will be more a pastoral reflection on the priorities of Jesus
Christ and how his values might help you and your fellow senators better care for
“the least of these” in America. (You probably recognize Jesus’ words in the
parable from Matthew 25).
Of course there are countless
differences between Jesus’ time and ours, but there are some timeless attitudes
he demonstrated and some abiding charges he delivered to those of us who dare
to wear his name: Christ-ian.
Since you
are a man who speaks openly about your Christian faith and since I am a
pastor, I want to believe you are continually seeking to grow in these fundamental
Christian disciplines.
1) Love God. Love Neighbor
Jesus was pretty clear about
priorities – his and ours: we are called to love God with heart, soul, strength and mind
and we are expected to love our neighbors as ourselves. He was also clear about
who is a neighbor and how we are to
be neighbor. (See the parable of the Good Samaritan in Luke chapter 10.)
In a nation such as America, our
citizens are free to understand and worship God as they see fit. As a Christian
minister, I am grateful for the bold vision of our Constitution and the way our
First Amendment protects people from state and federal incursions into our
religious practices. I believe very strongly in the separation of church and
state because I see how marrying religion and politics has deeply compromised both
our government and the church of Jesus Christ.
That said, Jesus’ call to be the neighbor and to love our neighbors can inform and
improve how Americans live together in our society for the common good. A
Christian discipline for the love of neighbor demands an unselfish generosity and
a willingness to sacrifice our own preferences and convenience for the good of
the other.
I am deeply concerned about our neighbors here in Texas and across
America; I am concerned that their own government is working against them
instead of for them. Those who finally have access to affordable health care may
lose it if you have your way; the push to repeal the Affordable Care Act sounds
selfish. Your pledge to work against immigration reform instead of working with
President Obama to find solutions sounds foolish. Your effort to undermine our
public school systems sounds short sighted. Such actions would undo the
progress we have made as a community of neighbors, a community that looks out
for one another: for “the widows and the orphans,” for the “little ones,” for
the “strangers" among us, for those who are trampled under the feet of the rich
and powerful. Your programs and policies that increase the benefits of the privileged
and compromise the possibilities of the underprivileged are not the way of the
Christ.
2) More is Less and First is Last
As you read your Bible, surely
you have read Jesus’ words that proclaim “the least among you is the greatest;”
that the “last shall be first and the first shall be last.” Throughout the
story of Scripture, God has always honored humility. One of my favorite
biblical characters is Jesus’ own mother who responded to the news of the
coming Messiah with a prophetic song:
God has brought
down the powerful from their thrones,
and lifted up the
lowly;
God has filled the
hungry with good things,
and sent the rich
away empty.
Mary’s Magnificat celebrates God’s mysterious, upside-down-way in the
world that honors the poor and lifts up the oppressed. When followers of the
Christ acknowledge that same reality in our own day, then we too must do
whatever we can to speak for those who have no voice, to stand for those who
have no standing, to align ourselves with those who are maligned and dismissed
by the rich and the powerful.
I am deeply concerned about the
gridlock in Congress that keeps you from cooperating together to work for the
common good of ALL the people of America. These days – even more than most -
you elected officials of Congress seem to be representing your own interests
instead of the interests of those you are elected to represent. There is too
much self-promotion and preening, too much self-righteousness and condemnation.
There is too much hubris and not near enough humility. Your inflammatory language is inexcusable. Your refusal to compromise with your colleagues is harmful. Your unwillingness to consider all sides of any issue is small minded. Your alignment with the rich and powerful is not the way of the Christ.
There is too much hubris and not near enough humility. Your inflammatory language is inexcusable. Your refusal to compromise with your colleagues is harmful. Your unwillingness to consider all sides of any issue is small minded. Your alignment with the rich and powerful is not the way of the Christ.
Senator Cruz, this effort of mine to do pastoral
and theological reflection on the work and role of our elected officials is my
resolution for this new year. I have complained enough; now I will be sending
my insights and suggestions directly to you since you are my
Texas Senator. I plan to follow your work and to communicate with you
frequently throughout the year.
Please feel free to communicate back to me – preferably with a real letter (rather than a form letter) so that we can have an honest dialogue about the appropriate intersections of faith and public life in America.
Please feel free to communicate back to me – preferably with a real letter (rather than a form letter) so that we can have an honest dialogue about the appropriate intersections of faith and public life in America.
Grace and Peace,
Reverend Charlotte Vaughan Coyle
Paris TX
Charlotte is an ordained minister within the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ).
Right on!
ReplyDeleteThanks! I hope you will write your own letter to your senator.
DeletePeace...
Dear Charlotte,
ReplyDeleteDo they have female pastors now in Texas? How in God's name did that happen?
Yours in Christ,
Ted Cruz
Perfect!
DeleteThat you are a female pastor, in Cruz's eyes most likely disqualifies you as a true representative of Christ.
DeleteI am of the belief that religion represents the opinions, feelings and biases of the individual rather that the other way around......You can always find something to justify what you want to believe...
I don't disagree that religion is our human effort to search for the Holy, what is beyond us. When done well, that search makes us bigger and better and we are able to see and affirm so many others who are on this journey. When done poorly, religion becomes tribal, exclusive and self-justifying. Throughout history, people have used religion for power. Not at all what I read in my Christian Scriptures. Thanks for your comment.
DeleteI agree with everything you've said and applaud your New Year's Resolution. Keep up the good work.
ReplyDeleteThanks Sally. I hope to send a letter once a month. Maybe you could write to your senators as well. We're all in this together.
DeleteThanks Lee. I hope you will write your own letter to your representatives.
ReplyDeleteThanks Dorcie. Consider writing to your senators as well. It takes all our voices.
ReplyDeleteI think my Senators and Congressmen are tired of hearing from me. It does not seem to make any difference what you/I or anyone else says to them. I will continue to write and email - hopefully, somebody/someday will hear us. I get many many form letters in answer. Loved your letter. If that response is really from Mr Cruz, he is more of an idiot than I thought.
ReplyDeleteLet's both keep up the good work, Judi. We never know when truth will break through. (no that was a joke; I haven't heard from Mr. Cruz.)
DeletePeace...
If he replies I am sure it will start ... Dear Charlotte, I am not a Theologian, but,,,
ReplyDeleteGreat letter!
ReplyDeleteThanks Deb. "I am not a theologian but I play one on TV..." ?!
Delete:)
I hope you will write your own letter. It takes all of us.
Peace...
Nicely said! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks Suzanne. I hope you will write your own letter. One letter may not make much difference but a flood of letters may. Peace...
DeleteDear Pastor Charlotte
ReplyDeleteI am not a person of faith though I was raised a Catholic. I would like to applaud you for being some one who has the courage to point out Mr Cruz's hypocrisy. Though he's one of many on both sides. Pointing these things out from my side of the fence holds little to no weight as we are viewed by some to be soul less heathens with no moral compass. I would love to see if he actually engages you in dialog.
Godspeed!
PS...My screen name is taken from an obscure 60's film. I'm a decent fellow. Ask my mom. :)
Ha! Great screen name. It ought to be my name! Thanks for the encouragement. I plan to send a letter each month so I'll post them and we will all see what happens. You know as well as I do that one doesn't need religion to have a moral compass; please do write your own letter to your senators. It takes all of us. Peace ...
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThank you for that great letter, while I'm not sure that I believe in God I continue to follow Jesus's teachings as best I can.
ReplyDeleteWe can't go wrong following Jesus' teachings, Ray. What we do always speaks louder than what we say. Thanks for your encouraging words.
DeleteA simply brilliant letter written on behalf of the Kingdom.
ReplyDeleteThanks Sergio. I pray wisdom and courage for all of us.
DeleteRun for Senate.
ReplyDeleteHa! Maybe YOU should run! :)
DeleteThank you for your new year's resolution and your courage. You are an inspiration and cause us to step out in hope. Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Alice Paul, and all the brave women in our history are smiling down on you. Keep up the amazing work. We are all in this together.
ReplyDeleteWe do stand on the shoulders of some amazing people, don't we? I sometimes wonder what my life today might have been without their courage. We MUST honor them and keep this crucial work going. Yes indeed; we are all in this together. Thanks again for your encouraging words.
DeleteThank you for your new year's resolution and your courage. You are an inspiration and cause us to step out in hope. Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Alice Paul, and all the brave women in our history are smiling down on you. Keep up the amazing work. We are all in this together.
ReplyDelete